Keep Your Freezer Stocked All Summer Long With the Best Mail Order Ice Creams

Best Overall

Graeter's Ice Cream Assorted 6-Pack

View on Goldbelly.com

If you've never tried French Pot ice cream, now's a perfect time! Graeter's ice creams are unique and have been for over 150 years. They're made by the same method this Cincinnati ice cream parlor has been using since it opened in 1870. The specialized technique they've developed can produce only 2 gallons at a time so this is truly a "Slow Food" product made by artisans.

A custard-based ice cream, the texture is dense, rich, and creamy but still soft with concentrated fresh-tasting flavors. With over 20 options to choose from, there's something for all tastes: Try the S'mores, the Oregon Strawberry, the Vienna Coffee, or the all-time-bestseller Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip that is fruity and filled with fudgy hunks of chocolate. The "Choose Your Own 6 Pints" is perfect for testing, tasting, and undoubtedly falling in love.

"Graeter's Ice Cream is unlike any ice cream out there thanks to its super thick consistency and sweet taste," says updates editor Amanda McDonald. "Out of all the flavors, you can't go wrong with one of the many chocolate chip options—the chunks of soft, sweet, and heavy chocolate are delicious with any flavor."

Number of pints: 6 | Ships: Monday through Friday | Flavors available: Black Cherry Chocolate Chip, Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, Buckeye Blitz Chocolate Chip, Butter Pecan, Chocolate Chip, Chunky Chunky Hippo, Coconut Chocolate Chip, Cookie & Cream, Cookie Dough Chocolate Chip, Dark Chocolate Brownie, Double Chocolate Chip, Dutch Milk Chocolate, Lemon Sorbet, Madagascar Vanilla Bean, Mint Chocolate Chip, Mocha Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, Oregon Strawberry, Original Salted Caramel, Raspberry Sorbet, Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip, S’Mores, Toffee Chocolate Chip, and Vienna Coffee

Best for Gifting

Life Raft Treats Ice Cream Bucket

View on Goldbelly.com

Created by pastry chef Cynthia Wong, a six-time James Beard Award finalist, this looks like a bucket of fried chicken, but take a bite and guess what? The drumstick is actually made from waffle ice cream on a “bone" made from a chocolate-covered cookie and covered with white chocolate and crushed corn flakes—made to look like a battered crust on a fried chicken drumstick! These are amazing, utterly delicious, and tons of fun. The ingredients are all high-end, too.

Number of pints: N/A | Ships: Tuesdays and Thursdays | Flavors available: Waffle Ice Cream

Best Flavor Variety

Jeni's Ice Cream

View on Jenis.com View on Instacart.com

Founder Jeni Britton started ice cream recipe developing over two decades ago and has since built Jeni's into a multi-city ice cream shop empire. The brand now has a loyal following for a few reasons: One is the quality of the ice cream—it's smooth, creamy, and each bite tastes incredibly fresh. Another is because the offerings are available on Amazon and other online sites and not just in the brick-and-mortar Jeni's Ice Cream shops.

"Jeni’s is my hands down favorite ice cream out there. Not only because she uses real ingredients and has an exciting menu of pints (looking at you, Coconut Cream Cold Brew) but because she has methodically approached the recipe for each and every flavor, so that even old-classics like Chocolate, Strawberry, or Vanilla coat your tongue just-right and deliver rich flavor," says food editor Kristin Stangl.

And by far the biggest reason is the unique twists on traditional flavors like Darkest Chocolate, Salty Caramel, Strawberry Buttermilk, and Honey Vanilla Bean that don't taste like the cartons at the grocery store. The small changes, like making chocolate super dark or adding a hint of honey to vanilla, elevates these flavors far beyond others. It is slightly pricier per pint than other mail-order ice creams, but for good reason, and you won't regret it.

Number of pints: N/A | Ships: Daily | Flavors available: Brambleberry Crisp, Salty Caramel, Brown Butter Almond Brittle, Darkest Chocolate, Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks, Gooey Butter Cake, Cookies In Cream, Green Mint Chip, Wedding Cake, Buttercream Birthday Cake, High Five Candy Bar, Goat Cheese with Red Cherries, Lemon & Blueberries Parfait, Powdered Jelly Donut, Skillet Cinnamon Roll, Middle West Whiskey & Pecans, Golden Nectar, Pumpkin Cake Roll, Frosé, Strawberry Buttermilk, Coffee with Cream & Sugar, Milkiest Chocolate, Sweet Cream Biscuits & Peach Jam, Brandied Banana Brûlée, Wildberry Lavender, Honey Vanilla Bean, Non-Dairy Cold Brew with Coconut Cream, Boston Cream Pie, Savannah Buttermint, Non-Dairy Dark Chocolate Truffle, Cream Puff, Pineapple Upside Down Cake, Non-Dairy Banana Cream Pudding

Best Mochi

My/Mo Mochi Ice Cream Mixed Pack

$104 at Amazon $5 at Walmart View on Instacart.com

The combination of the Japanese sweet mochi put together with creamy ice cream is absolutely irresistible. Add to that the fact that these are basically finger foods and everyone’s in for a fun, delicious experience. Each mochi is about the size of a golf ball and fits in the palm of your hand. The outer rice dough is sweet, smooth, and chewy, perfectly blending with the creamy ice cream inside.

Some flavors to try include Cookies & Cream, Sweet Mango, Double Chocolate, Ripe Strawberry, Cereal & Milk, Horchata, Matcha Green Tea, S'mores, Pumpkin Spice, Salted Caramel, Cool Peppermint, Guava, Dulce De Leche, Mint Chocolate Chip, and more. Make it a special occasion by whipping up some Japanese rice crackers as an accompaniment.

Number of pints: N/A | Ships: Daily | Flavors available: Mango, Strawberry, Mint Chocolate Chip, Cookies & Cream, Double Chocolate, Vanilla Bean, Passion Fruit, Coffee, Ube, Strawberry with Boba, Cereal & Milk, Mint Chocolate Chip, Horchata, S'mores, Matcha Green Tea, Dulce De Leche, Coconut, Guava, Cool Peppermint, Pumpkin Spice, Apple Pie a la Mode, Salted Caramel, and Chocolate

Best Unique Flavors

Malai Signature Ice Cream

View on Goldbelly.com

Malai Ice Cream is all about small-batch ice cream in some very enticing and sophisticated flavors, such as Rose with Cinnamon Roasted Almonds, Masala Chai, Orange Fennel, and Sweet Milk. These internationally influenced flavor profiles are the future of ice cream—and the hand-churned low-air texture of the final product intensifies both the flavors and the sensation of richness. End result: This tastes like luxury. For a very special dessert, make some delicious jalebi to serve along with the ice cream.

Number of pints: 4 | Ships: Monday and Wednesday | Flavors available: Rose with Cinnamon Roasted Almonds, Masala Chai, Orange Fennel, and Sweet Milk

Best Ice Cream Sandwiches

La Newyorkina Babka Ice Cream Sandwiches

View on Goldbelly.com

We love this innovation in the form of an ice cream sandwich made by Fanny Gerson of Newyorkina in Brooklyn. It's made with an outside of rich handmade chocolate babka baked with a hint of cinnamon and a lot of Mexican chocolate and sandwiched with smooth vanilla ice cream. Made by Gerson of Newyorkina, inspired by Gerson's Mexican roots and launched in 2010, this combination is simply out-of-this-world delicious and extremely Instagrammable. The decadent ice cream sandwiches come in a pack of six.

Number of pints: N/A | Ships: Monday through Friday | Flavors available: Oaxaca Chocolate and Mexican Vanilla

Best Keto

Rebel The Maverick Mixed Case Ice Cream

$64 at Amazon

Rebel is lactose-free, no sugar added, low-carb keto ice cream. For people on the keto diet, each container clearly specifies how many net carbs per pint—which ranges from 4 to 8 grams, depending on the flavor. The flavor selection in this collection consists of a pint each of Cookes & Cream, Triple Chocolate, Vanilla, Salted Caramel, Coconut Almond Swirl, Black Raspberry, and Peanut Butter Fudge but other flavor selections are also available.

Number of pints: 8 | Ships: Daily | Flavors available: Cookies & Cream, Salted Caramel, Black Raspberry, Triple Chocolate, Cherry Chip, Coconut Almond Swirl, Peanut Butter Cup, and Vanilla

Best for Parties

Williams Sonoma Baked Alaska & Crème Brûlée Mini Ice Cream Cakes

$95 at Williams Sonoma

If you’re looking for an ice cream dessert for a special occasion, these mini ice cream cakes are tremendously elegant, to the point where they give people the idea that a private chef must be in your kitchen. The package comes with a selection of two types—Baked Alaska and crème brûlée—with six of each. Really wow your guests at your next dinner party or elevate an engagement party with minimal work on your part: Simply pull them out of the freezer when it's time and enjoy frozen. These would also be wonderful for an afternoon tea party (they are picture-perfect, after all), following tea sandwiches. They are shipped frozen and can be stored unopened in the freezer for up to three months so you can plan ahead for all your soirees.

Number of pints: N/A | Ships: Daily | Flavors available: Baked Alaska and Crème Brûlé

Best Dairy-Free

Crank & Boom Dairy-Free Ice Cream Collection

View on Goldbelly.com

Crank & Boom out of Lexington, Kentucky uses locally sourced ingredients to make great traditional American ice cream flavors such as Chocolate Fudge Ripple, Cookies & (No) Cream, Banana + Chocolate, Strawberry Fields, Bourbon & Honey, and Coconut Caramel Delight in a dairy-free form that won’t make you feel like you’re missing anything at all. They use coconut cream as their base and a small-batch handcrafted method that gives a smooth texture with intense flavors. Any of these ice cream flavors could be paired with a good Kentucky bourbon.

Number of pints: 6 | Ships: Monday through Thursday | Flavors available: Non-Dairy Chocolate Fudge Ripple, Non-Dairy Cookies & No Cream, Non-Dairy Banana + Chocolate, Non-Dairy Strawberry Fields, Non-Dairy Bourbon & Honey, and Non-Dairy Coconut Caramel Delight

Best Allergen-Free

A La Mode Speed Bump & Cooks Ice Cream

$59 at Walmart View on Goldbelly.com

A La Mode ice creams are made by people who take allergens seriously. With no nuts, eggs, or sesame, these are really excellent options for those who want to avoid certain ingredients. In this collection are two flavors: Cooks, which is a vanilla ice cream base stirred with chocolate fudge and a vanilla and chocolate cookie mix in, and Speed Bump, which is a chocolate ice cream base mixed with chips of white and dark chocolate along with marshmallows.

Number of pints: 6 | Ships: Daily | Flavors available: Cooks and Speed Bump